The phone rings in every town you serve.
Why did our traffic, or our AI visibility, drop after a website redesign?
One of five things, in order of likelihood: changed addresses without redirects; pages deleted or merged; the site still blocked from search after staging; titles and headings rewritten so Google no longer matches them; or your analytics changed at the same time and the drop is in the measurement, not the visitors. The last one is more common than people think.
This is the question I get after a redesign done elsewhere, and the first thing I say is: check the measurement before you panic about the site.
1. Is the drop real?
Open Search Console, not Google Analytics. Search Console counts impressions and clicks on Google’s side, so cookie banners, consent settings, a new tag or a broken one cannot touch it. If Search Console is flat and Analytics has collapsed, your tracking changed, not your traffic. New sites often launch with consent mode set properly for the first time, and the “drop” is the visitors who were always declining cookies and are now, correctly, not counted.
2. Redirects
Take the ten pages that had the most clicks before the redesign and open their old addresses. A 404 on any of them is your answer. Add a one-to-one redirect to the replacement page today; Google forgives this quickly if fixed within weeks.
3. Deleted or merged pages
A redesign tidies. Six service pages become one, the blog is pruned, the location pages are folded into a map. Each deleted page took its rankings with it. Restore the ones that had traffic, or redirect them to the closest surviving page.
4. Blocked from search
Look at the page source for a robots tag saying noindex, and at Settings, Reading in WordPress for the “discourage search engines” box. Staging sites are blocked on purpose and that setting travels with the database at launch.
5. Rewritten titles and headings
Compare the old and new title of a page that fell. “Plumbers in Mississauga” rewritten as “We’ve got you covered” is a page Google no longer understands.
Why AI visibility drops too
ChatGPT and Perplexity cite paragraphs that answer a question on their own. Redesigns break those paragraphs into bullets, move them under hero images, or replace them with slogans. The citation goes to a site that still has the paragraph. Put the plain answers back, near the top, in full sentences.
How long until it recovers
Redirects and unblocking: two to four weeks. Restored pages: four to eight. Rewritten content put back: a couple of months. If nothing above applies and the drop is real, it is time for a proper audit.
How I estimate: a free audit to see where you stand now, back within three working days. Then a quick chat, then a fixed quote.